GREAT BAY--A customer of Real Auto car dealership is seeking a refund or settlement of her outstanding vehicle loan following nearly three years of recurring mechanical complaints involving a 2023 Chevrolet Tracker purchased from Real Auto.
The dispute has resulted in formal legal correspondence, repeated requests for diagnostic and maintenance records, and direct communication with the vehicle's manufacturer after the customer says several attempts to resolve the problem through the dealership were unsuccessful.
The customer, who requested anonymity, purchased the vehicle new on December 21, 2022, with a three-year manufacturer's warranty that expired in December 2025. According to her account and correspondence submitted by her attorneys, an intermittent noise developed during 2023 and was subsequently reported to Real Auto's service department.
She maintains that the vehicle was returned to the dealership on more than four occasions for inspections and repairs, but the noise continued to recur despite the work reportedly performed.
The customer explained that the problem was particularly difficult to address because the noise was intermittent, sometimes disappearing during inspections before returning afterward. She said dealership representatives were able to hear the noise during certain test drives, but the interventions that followed did not produce a lasting resolution.
At one stage, the dealership reportedly attributed the noise to the braking system and then the environment. The customer said she paid to have the brakes replaced during a scheduled service in December 2025, but approximately one week later, the same noise returned.
She subsequently brought the vehicle back to Real Auto, where representatives accompanied her on a test drive. According to the customer, the noise was acknowledged and additional work was performed, but the problem later resurfaced.
Formal correspondence sent to Real Auto on June 9, 2026, confirms that the customer reported another occurrence in January 2026, shortly after the warranty expired. The letter states that the vehicle was inspected during a test drive with a service department supervisor and that the customer was informed the issue had been resolved.
Approximately two weeks later, according to the correspondence, the noise returned.
During another test drive involving a dealership representative, the customer was reportedly informed that the sound could be attributed to the condition or infrastructure of the roadway rather than the vehicle itself.
The customer disputes that explanation and maintains that the underlying cause of the noise has never been satisfactorily established.
Attorneys raise questions about warranty obligations
In formal correspondence dated June 9, 2026, attorneys representing the customer contacted Real Auto's management regarding the recurring mechanical issue and the dealership's handling of the complaints.
The correspondence referenced Article 7:17 of St. Maarten's Civil Code, which concerns a seller's obligation to deliver products that conform to the purchase agreement and possess the qualities a purchaser may reasonably expect.
The attorneys raised questions about the dealership's responsibilities when a mechanical complaint arises during the warranty period but remains unresolved despite repeated inspections and repair attempts.
They requested a complete service, maintenance and diagnostic history, written confirmation of the cause of the noise and a detailed plan to resolve the problem.
The letter also requested a replacement vehicle during further inspections or repairs and consideration of extended warranty protection or manufacturer-backed coverage if the issue could not reasonably be resolved.
Real Auto was given 14 days to respond in writing, with the customer reserving the right to pursue further legal action.
Real Auto has not responded.
Customer alleges difficulty obtaining service records
A significant part of the dispute concerns the customer's attempts to obtain documentation detailing the inspections and repairs performed on her vehicle.
She alleges that dealership employees repeatedly provided verbal explanations but failed to supply complete written diagnostic findings or a consolidated service history.
According to the customer, a service advisor initially agreed to provide the records, but she was subsequently informed that approval from the general manager was required before they could be released.
She claims that requests made directly to management and through her attorneys have not resulted in the complete documentation being provided.
The legal correspondence identifies a diagnostic assessment conducted on May 11, 2026. The customer maintains that she has not received the full findings, which she considers necessary to establish what work was performed and why the problem persists.
Chevrolet manufacturer contacted
The customer eventually contacted Chevrolet's manufacturer and spoke with a regional representative responsible for the Caribbean.
According to her account, she was informed that the manufacturer's records initially contained no complaint associated with her vehicle identification number, despite her repeated visits to Real Auto.
She further alleges that the manufacturer's representative attempted to obtain diagnostic information from the dealership but was informed that certain documents were considered internal records.
The customer said the representative discussed possible assistance, including extending warranty coverage and covering additional repair expenses.
However, she requested that a manufacturer-appointed technician examine the vehicle directly rather than returning it to Real Auto for further inspections.
Additional vehicle and maintenance concerns
The customer also reported that carpeting beneath the driver's pedals began lifting within approximately six months of ownership, creating a bulge near the brake pedal.
She said the condition raised concerns about possible interference with the pedals and questioned why temporary transportation was not provided while the matter was being addressed. There is no independent assessment establishing that the carpeting affected the vehicle's operation.
Another disagreement involves servicing intervals. The customer said Real Auto questioned whether maintenance had consistently been performed according to the required schedule.
She maintains that she generally relied on mileage when determining servicing intervals and disputes whether this should affect the dealership's handling of a problem first reported during the warranty period.
Customer rejects trade-in, seeks financial settlement
According to the customer, Real Auto previously suggested trading in the Chevrolet Tracker for a newer vehicle. She rejected the proposal, explaining that the vehicle was financed through a loan and that replacing it would require refinancing.
Her original request was for the recurring noise to be permanently resolved, warranty protection to be extended and temporary transportation to be provided during repairs.
After repeated unsuccessful attempts, she is now requesting that Real Auto accept the return of the vehicle and either refund the purchase price or settle the outstanding loan balance.
The customer also claims to be aware of other vehicle owners who have sought legal assistance in separate disputes involving Real Auto. Those accounts, including the circumstances and outcomes of any proceedings, have not been independently verified.
The customer maintains that the matter remains unresolved, with the requested financial settlement and complete service documentation still outstanding. Real Auto's position on the customer's allegations and proposed settlement has not been established in the information reviewed.
(Editor's note: Real Auto was contacted to provide comment before this article was publish and did not respond to the request).