MARIGOT--President of the Collectivité of Saint-Martin Louis Mussington has defended his handling of the political crisis unfolding on the French side, insisting that the emergence of a new majority in the Territorial Council does not give its members the authority to disregard established procedures or dictate how he exercises his presidential responsibilities.
Speaking on SOS Radio 95.9 on Monday, November 16, during an interview with Billy D, Mussington addressed the dramatic developments of November 13 and 14, which saw his political camp lose its majority in the 23-member Territorial Council and opposition-aligned councillors secure three positions in a newly constituted Executive Council.
The president accused his political opponents of attempting to force decisions without following the proper procedures. He warned that the dispute could delay significant government projects, including the proposed €38 million acquisition of nearly 200 hectares of Beauperthuy land, and affect other decisions that must be taken before the March 2027 territorial elections.
However, while maintaining that his opponents were pursuing political power at the expense of the territory's interests, Mussington also acknowledged that mistakes had been made during his administration and said he would approach certain matters differently if given another opportunity.
How the political balance changed
The current confrontation follows divisions within the Rassemblement Saint-Martinois Alternative (RSMA), the political grouping that brought Mussington to office in 2022.
Those divisions became increasingly apparent during September's senatorial election, which resulted in former Collectivité President Daniel Gibbs being elected to the French Senate. The departure of several councillors from Mussington's governing camp left him with 11 supporters against a newly aligned group of 12.
Friday's Territorial Council meeting brought that changed political balance into focus.
A vote initially intended to address the Executive Council vacancy created by Gibbs' departure developed into a broader election of all six executive members.
The list led by Mélissa Nicolas-Rembotte received 12 votes, compared with 11 for the list headed by Alain Richardson. Under the electoral system governing the process, each list secured three positions.
Nicolas-Rembotte became First Vice President, replacing Richardson. Martine Beldor was elected Second Vice President, former senator Annick Pétrus became Third Vice President, and Dominique Louisy assumed the position of Fourth Vice President.
Richardson and Bernadette Davis retained places on the Executive Council as members, while Michel Petit lost his position.
Despite the opposition's success in securing three executive positions, Mussington remains president and retains a narrow four-to-three majority on the Executive Council when his own membership is included.
The result creates an unusual governing situation in which the president no longer commands a majority in the full Territorial Council but retains a majority within the smaller body responsible for important executive decisions.
Dispute over authority and council procedures
Mussington acknowledged during Monday's interview that the opposing councillors have secured 12 votes but rejected the suggestion that this allows them to determine every aspect of the council's proceedings.
"They're trying to bully their way through," he said, arguing that the law must still be respected.
The disagreement centers partly on four proposals submitted by councillors seeking changes to the way the Collectivité is governed.
These include reconsidering powers previously delegated by the Territorial Council to the Executive Council, changing the Collectivité's representation on the boards of SEMSAMAR and the Saint-Martin Tourism Office, and revisiting decisions relating to the Beauperthuy land acquisition.
Mussington explained that he had received the requests and responded by referring to provisions of the French legal framework governing the Collectivité. He maintained that although the councillors were entitled to request consideration of the proposals, the law did not require him to place them before the assembly immediately.
He also defended his decision to suspend proceedings rather than allow the new majority to proceed with appointments he said had not been properly included on the agenda.
His opponents have challenged that interpretation.
According to reporting by SoualigaPost and Faxinfo, councillors in the new majority argued that they were exercising their legal rights and seeking access to information and decision-making processes they considered insufficiently transparent.
They maintained that the reorganization of the Executive Council justified reconsidering appointments to commissions and outside organizations.
The disagreement led to repeated interruptions during Friday's sitting and a further confrontation when councillors returned on Saturday, November 14. The 12-member group eventually walked out, leaving the meeting without sufficient members to continue.
Mussington said he intends to meet with the three newly elected vice presidents to discuss their responsibilities. However, he maintained that decisions concerning the distribution of portfolios and authority to sign documents on his behalf fall within his presidential powers.
€38 million Beauperthuy acquisition at risk, Mussington warns
One of Mussington's strongest warnings concerned the proposed acquisition of approximately 200 hectares of Beauperthuy land for €38 million.
The president said the transaction, being pursued through the public land agency Terres Caraïbes, represents an opportunity to secure property for future housing, public infrastructure and development.
"The land is the future of a country. There's no land, there's no future," Mussington declared.
He placed particular emphasis on the need to preserve land for younger generations, including Saint-Martin residents studying abroad who may eventually wish to return home.
According to Mussington, the land could eventually support affordable housing lots, residential developments and public infrastructure that would otherwise become increasingly difficult to accommodate.
The president said financing arrangements involving the Banque des Territoires were expected to advance during the first week of December.
He warned that further delays could jeopardize the acquisition because a court-appointed administrator overseeing the property may be able to resume the auction process if the transaction does not proceed.
Mussington accused his opponents of attempting to delay the agreement until the opportunity had passed.
However, the councillors seeking a further review have framed their demands differently.
Their proposal calls for a dedicated Territorial Council meeting to examine the acquisition, provide councillors with the complete documentation and suspend the signing of additional purchase documents or payments until the matter has been reviewed.
Mussington maintained that the council had already approved the acquisition and that the necessary documents had previously been made available.
He also argued that the transaction had already undergone the required legal review, although the precise consequences of that process and the legality of any renewed deliberation remain matters of contention.
The president appealed directly to residents, particularly young people, to attend the next council meeting dealing with the acquisition and make their views known peacefully.
He promised to convene the meeting as quickly as possible, while maintaining that its scheduling must follow the applicable procedures.
President disputes claims about Collectivité's finances
Mussington also used the interview to challenge public claims about the Collectivité's financial position, particularly allegations that its debts amount to approximately €200 million.
He rejected that figure and defended two proposed loans totaling approximately €3.7 million, which he said are intended to complete important public facilities.
Approximately €3.2 million would be used to continue work on the médiathèque in Concordia, while another €500,000 would support the Maison des Associations project in Grand Case.
Mussington said the loans would help advance construction and meet obligations to contractors without placing unnecessary strain on the Collectivité's available cash.
He indicated that the annual repayment on the proposed financing would be approximately €162,000.
The president also challenged claims concerning outstanding payments to construction companies, saying industry representatives had identified approximately €20 million in claims rather than the €56 million that had been publicly alleged.
He said the Collectivité was working with contractors to review documentation and settle outstanding amounts.
Mussington further stated that the initial 2026 budget was €276 million and that the overall budget had subsequently reached €351 million.
These financial figures were presented by Mussington during the interview and have not been independently reconciled with the Collectivité's complete financial statements.
Proposed constitutional changes could also be affected
Looking beyond the immediate confrontation, Mussington warned that the political divisions could complicate discussions over proposed changes to the organic law governing Saint-Martin.
He said he expects French President Emmanuel Macron to visit the territory on December 11 and announce measures related to the Collectivité's powers and responsibilities.
According to Mussington, discussions with French authorities have focused on providing Saint-Martin with greater decision-making authority in areas where local matters remain dependent on administrative structures elsewhere in France.
He referred particularly to education, including school administration and the replacement of teachers, as well as responsibilities involving coastal property, environmental management and infrastructure.
The president said the Territorial Council would need to consider proposals connected to these reforms before the relevant legislative process could advance in France.
He expressed concern that political disagreements within the council might undermine work that had already progressed through discussions with French authorities.
Mussington also indicated that he intends to hold discussions with Senator Daniel Gibbs concerning the reforms, recognizing the importance of Saint-Martin's representation when the proposals eventually reach the French Senate.
The expected presidential visit and the scope of the proposed changes were described by Mussington and remain subject to official confirmation.
Possible no-confidence motion
The president also addressed the possibility of a motion of no confidence being introduced against him.
He said the possibility had been raised during discussions with members of the new majority and acknowledged that councillors have legal mechanisms available to challenge his leadership.
However, he insisted that any such process would have to comply with the relevant legal requirements.
Mussington said he was not intimidated by the prospect of being removed from office and suggested that residents should ultimately be allowed to decide the territory's political direction through the elections scheduled for March 2027.
He also confirmed having held discussions with two members of the opposing group in an effort to determine whether cooperation remained possible.
At the same time, he acknowledged that his own administration had not been without mistakes and indicated that he had learned important lessons from his time in office.
Nevertheless, he maintained that the remaining months of the mandate should be devoted to completing projects and taking decisions in the territory's interest rather than extending political disputes.
The president warned that if the 12-member bloc consistently votes against government proposals, the Collectivité could face difficulties advancing important matters.
"We could be in trouble. Let's face, that's the reality," he acknowledged.
The latest developments leave Saint-Martin facing a politically divided Territorial Council, an Executive Council in which Mussington retains a narrow majority, and several significant decisions awaiting resolution.
With territorial elections approximately four months away, the immediate question is whether the competing political groups can find sufficient common ground to continue governing or whether the confrontation will intensify.
For Mussington, the priority remains advancing the administration's existing projects. For the councillors challenging his leadership, the dispute has become a test of transparency, legal procedure and the authority of the Territorial Council.
How those competing positions are resolved will determine the functioning of Saint-Martin's government during the final months of its current mandate.