Loading...
Loading...
Loading...

Court of Appeal confirms conviction of former MP

November 27, 2025

Court of Appeal confirms conviction of former MP
Loading...

SINT MAARTEN (GREAT BAY) - The Court of Appeal has delivered its ruling in the criminal case against former Member of Parliament A.A., confirming the earlier conviction related to election-fraud offenses.

The Court upheld the original conviction and provided additional reasoning in support of its decision.

Loading...

In its findings, the Court concluded that A.A. knowingly engaged in conduct connected to the 2024 election period involving vote-buying. While the Court held that election fraud, in principle, warrants an unconditional prison sentence, it determined that a reduced sentence was appropriate in light of A.A.’s personal circumstances following the end of his parliamentary function, the significant social impact of the proceedings within a small island community, and the fact that a forfeiture measure would also be imposed.

In its ruling, the Court imposed a one-year prison sentence, which will be fully suspended, combined with a probation period of three years. The Court also ordered 90 hours of community service.

In addition, A.A. is barred from serving as a police officer for six years and is disqualified from eligibility in elections for a period of six years. According to the Court, these sanctions reflect the seriousness of conduct that undermines the integrity of democratic processes and the administration of justice.

The Court also emphasized that honesty in judicial proceedings and integrity in public roles are fundamental to maintaining public confidence in democratic institutions. The ruling of the Court of Appeal is now final unless further legal remedies are pursued under applicable law.

The Court also issued rulings for co-defendants F. and M., confirming both convictions. For F., the original judgment remained in place with one evidentiary omission. For M., the Court upheld the conviction but adjusted the sentence to a fully suspended six-month prison term, a three-year probation period, and 90 hours of community service.

Separately, the Court issued a ruling in the forfeiture proceedings (ontnemingszaak). This decision follows the earlier ruling of several weeks ago, which had rejected the forfeiture request at first instance, and was now reviewed on appeal.

The Court found that no financial benefit could be directly linked to the vote-buying itself, since it could not be established whether A.A. would have been elected without any unlawfully obtained votes.

However, in line with the arguments brought forward by the Prosecutor’s Office, the Court determined that a false oath on 10 February 2024 enabled A.A. to take his parliamentary seat and receive salary and therefore constituted an unlawful financial advantage.

In that oath, as required under Article 56 of the Staatsregeling of Sint Maarten, A.A. affirmed that he had not given or promised anything in connection with his election.

As a result, the Court ordered forfeiture of received salary in the amount of Cg 75,372, after deducting US $2,000 in estimated costs. This forfeiture order remains in force as part of the judgment. If the forfeiture amount is not paid in full, the Court ruled that replacement detention of one year may be imposed.

https://www.soualiganewsday.com/index.php?option=com_k2&view=item&id=63713:court-of-appeal-confirms-conviction-of-former-mp&Itemid=450

Source: http://www.sxm-talks.com/?guid=62ae8ed257140b2a27d1d91d99708df4

Loading...

Headlines

St. Maarten/St. Martin binational culinary team  arrives in Barbados for regional competition | The Daily Herald

November 16, 2026

St. Maarten/St. Martin binational culinary team arrives in Barbados for regional competition | The Daily Herald

From left: Jamal Dormoy (Junior Chef), Djaya Coupey (Pastry Chef), Lea Rojas (SHTA),Jewel Daal (senior chef), Renata de Weever (Coach), Erion Peterson (bartender / mixologist), Gina Illidge (STB), Paul Peterson (assistant Coach). PHILIPSBURG--St. Maarten/St. Martin is returnin...

November 15, 2026

US flights expected to normalize Sunday as PJIA advises travelers to check schedules | The Peoples Tribune

WASHINGTON--Air travel across the United States is expected to return to normal by Sunday evening following a nationwide grounding of flights that disrupted thousands of departures, stranded passengers and caused widespread delays across the aviation network. Federal Aviation...

November 14, 2026

Justice Ministry seeks Dutch police reinforcements amid surge in armed robberies | The Peoples Tribune

GREAT BAY--The Ministry of Justice has requested additional law enforcement assistance from the Netherlands and local security partners as authorities move to strengthen the Police Force of St. Maarten (KPSM) in response to an increase in armed robberies, firearm-related...

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...