Loading...
Loading...
Loading...

TERRITORIAL COUNCIL: The renewal of the executive precipitates a political crisis | Faxinfo

November 17, 2026

TERRITORIAL COUNCIL: The renewal of the executive precipitates a political crisis | Faxinfo
Loading...

MARIGOT - On November 13 and 14, the Territorial Council got stuck in a kind of institutional standoff. After renewing its executive on Friday, the elected officials met the next day to try to sort out the issue of reorganizing committees and the Collectivity's representation in external organizations. But the disagreement between Louis Mussington and the new opposition, which now holds the majority in the assembly, didn’t get resolved. The two sessions were marked by heated exchanges, pointless debates, outbursts, repeated suspensions, and, in the end, the departure of the president and then the opposition members.

A simple replacement that reshuffles the cards

It all started with Daniel Gibbs resigning from the Executive Council after being elected to the Senate, since you can't hold both positions. So, the first discussion at the November 13 session was meant to fill the vacant seat. But with several candidates stepping up, the idea of renewing all six members of the executive came up. Two lists then went head-to-head in a proportional vote using the highest average method. The list led by Mélissa Nicolas Rembotte got 12 votes, while the one led by Alain Richardson got 11.

The allocation of the six seats resulted in an equal split between the two camps. Mélissa Nicolas Rembotte becomes the first vice president, followed by Martine Beldor (2nd VP), Annick Pétrus (3rd VP), and Dominique Louisy (4th VP). Alain Richardson and Bernadette Davis serve as members. Louis Mussington remains president of the executive.

Loading...

However, this new balance immediately raised questions about political representation within the territorial commissions and external organizations, especially Semsamar and the Tourist Office. The opposition believes that the renewal of the Executive Council should lead to a new distribution of seats (board/office) in these bodies, relying in particular on the provisions of Article LO 6321-25 of the organic law.

TERRITORIAL COUNCIL: The renewal of the executive precipitates a political crisis | Faxinfo

The disagreement is moving to the designations

As early as November 13, Daniel Gibbs had asked for four draft resolutions submitted by the opposition on October 23 to be added to the agenda. They were about the Territorial Council taking back powers delegated to the executive, the Collectivity’s representation at Semsamar, chaired by Alain Richardson, and at the tourism office, chaired by Valérie Damaseau, as well as the Beauperthuy land. Louis Mussington refused to review them at that session, citing the need to assess the consequences, especially legal ones. He assured they would be studied later. The debate lasted nearly an hour, and the new agenda, cut by three items, was ultimately rejected by 12 votes to 11.

The session resumed on Saturday, November 14, at noon instead of 11 a.m., after the president arrived late and apologized. The discussion quickly shifted back to the reshuffling of the committees. Louis Mussington said that replacing members of the Executive Council didn’t count as a change of term and that the appointments to the commissions couldn’t be discussed since they weren’t on the agenda. He still suggested setting up a joint committee to try to reach an agreement on how this possible reshuffling could happen.

A proposal that didn’t convince the opposition. "We don’t negotiate the law, we enforce it," insists Angeline Laurence. Philippe Philidor reminds that the organic law governs how the Collectivity operates and asks the president to respect the assembly’s powers. Daniel Gibbs also argues for the need to make new appointments and believes it’s up to the Territorial Council to decide through a democratic vote. Annick Pétrus warns: "If you refuse, it means you’re breaking the law." Mélissa Nicolas Rembotte emphasizes: "We’re not here to destabilize or go to war with any of you. We just want to stop the bleeding."

Une séance interrompue, l’opposition hausse le ton

Louis Mussington maintained his position, notably arguing that he wished to wait for the return of the legality check before considering the new executive as definitively installed. He also mentioned case law concerning Saint Barthélemy, in which a president had not replaced a resigning member of the Executive Council and had succeeded before the Council of State. He thus justified his caution, while recalling that the schedule for examining draft resolutions was, in his view, a presidential prerogative.

For his part, Alain Richardson, former 1st VP, considered that a change in the composition of the Executive Council did not automatically lead to a modification of the Community's representation in the satellite commissions and bodies. The debate therefore did not bring positions closer together. On the contrary.

After a 6th suspension of the session in two days, Mélissa Nicolas Rembotte announced that the opposition did not wish to continue the discussions under these conditions. She denounced a paralysis of institutions and indicated that opposition elected officials had no choice but to leave the chamber. Before doing so, the group tabled a motion requesting the urgent convening of a Territorial Emergency Council dedicated to the acquisition of Beauperthuy land, with the transmission of all necessary documents. Louis Mussington adjourned the session at 1:46 p.m., noting that the quorum was no longer met, and announced that he would consider this request.

The motion of no confidence now mentioned

In a statement released on November 15, the twelve plural opposition councilors gave a particularly harsh assessment of these two days. They claim that Louis Mussington has lost his political majority since the senatorial elections and reproach him for not drawing the institutional consequences of the new balance of the assembly. They contest his interpretation of the organic law and denounce an attempt to prevent the majority of elected officials from asserting their decisions.

The statement also broadens the criticism of the term's record, notably mentioning the multiplication of loans, the evolution of the payroll, the Air Antilles file, and Beauperthuy's land commitments. The elected officials say they have informed the State services and still say they are willing to take a final step toward dialogue.

Corn (But) the tone hardens on what follows. The opposition warns that if the president persists in opposing the exercise of the assembly's prerogatives, it could file a motion of no confidence under the conditions provided for by Article LO 6322-4 of the General Code of Local Authorities. On Monday morning, on SOS Radio, President Mussington assured he was not "worried." A threat that opens a new stage in the political standoff within the Collectivity. _Vx

See also: https://www.faxinfo.fr/conseil-territorial-un-simple-remplacement-qui-fait-basculer-la-seance-dans-la-crise/

Find the full statement from the twelve elected officials of the plural opposition of the Territorial Council of Saint-Martin:

President Louis Mussington lost his majority. His refusal to draw consequences

institutional powers now exposes it to a possible motion of no confidence.

Since last September's senatorial elections, Louis Mussington no longer has the political majority that allowed him to govern the Territorial Council. Yet he intends to continue exercising power as if nothing had changed. It is in this stubborn refusal to accept the new balances of our assembly that the institutional crisis of November 13 and 14 originates.

As early as October 23, six of us had referred the matter to the president, based on Article LO 6321-11 of the General Code of Local Authorities, so that four draft resolutions concerning the delegated powers to the Executive Council, the Collectivity's representation at SEMSAMAR and the Tourist Office, as well as the Beauperthuy land, could be examined. Louis Mussington refused to include them on the agenda, citing an interpretation of the organic law whose validity we firmly contest.

On November 13, following Daniel Gibbs's resignation from the Executive Council following his election to the Senate, the renewal of the six members other than the president, in accordance with article LO 6322-7, confirmed the new political balance: three seats, including the first three vice-presidencies, went to our plural opposition. We have therefore requested that the Territorial Council examine new appointments within its commissions and external organizations, as permitted by Articles LO 6321-25 and LO 6321-27. Louis Mussington opposed it once again.

Lacking a majority to enforce his decisions, Louis Mussington now seems determined to prevent the assembly's majority from being able to express itself. In this obstinacy, we denounce an authoritarian drift, where delaying tactics and political calculations take precedence over respect for institutions.

This desire to obstruct the debate is all the more worrying as the record of this term now calls for serious explanations. Multiplication of loans, explosion of the wage bill, Air Antilles fiasco, controversial commitments around the Beauperthuy land: all decisions that raise major questions about the state of our Collective's finances and the burdens left to future generations. At the end of a term whose disastrous record we denounce, Louis Mussington should be held accountable for his choices before the assembly, rather than obstruct its oversight.

After two days of dead-end discussions, we left the session, refusing to endorse these methods any further. State services have been informed. However, we remain willing to take a final step toward dialogue, in order to allow a resolution from the crisis that respects the rights of the assembly.

We ask Louis Mussington for no favor or political concession. We demand that the Territorial Council be able to exercise the prerogatives recognized to it by the organic law. These prerogatives belong to the assembly and, through it, to the people of Saint-Martin, whom it represents. They cannot depend on the goodwill of its president. If Louis Mussington persists in this path, he now faces the possibility of filing a motion of no confidence, under the conditions provided for by Article LO 6322-4 of the General Code of Local Authorities. We did not seek this solution, but his persistent refusal to allow the assembly to exercise its responsibilities could force us to consider this institutional recourse.

It is now up to him to break out of this deadlock or to bear its political consequences

Philippe PHILIDOR

Marie-Dominique RAMPHORT

Daniel Gibbs

Alain GROS-DESORMEAUX

Angéline LAURENCE

Jules CHARVILLE

Annick PETRUS

Mélissa Nicolas-REMBOTTE

Martine BELDOR

Valerie FONROSE

Bernadette VENTHOU-DUMAINE

Raphaël SANCHEZ-OROZCO

Source: https://faxinfo.fr/en/conseil-territorial-le-renouvellement-de-lexecutif-precipite-une-crise-politique/

Loading...

Headlines

Justice Ministry seeks Dutch police reinforcements amid surge in armed robberies | The Peoples Tribune

November 14, 2026

Justice Ministry seeks Dutch police reinforcements amid surge in armed robberies | The Peoples Tribune

GREAT BAY--The Ministry of Justice has requested additional law enforcement assistance from the Netherlands and local security partners as authorities move to strengthen the Police Force of St. Maarten (KPSM) in response to an increase in armed robberies, firearm-related...

November 12, 2026

Council of Ministers Approve 50% Cut in Gasoline Excise Tax Providing Additional Relief at the Pumps | Soualiganewsday

SINT MAARTEN (POND ISLAND) - Following a joint initiative by the Ministries of Tourism, Economic Affairs, Traffic and Telecommunication (TEATT), Finance and Justice, the Council of Ministers has approved a 50% reduction in the excise tax on gasoline. This measure will bring th...

November 10, 2026

UPDATE on Kidnapping Investigation. One Victim Located, Police Appeal for Information on Second Victim | Soualiganewsday

SINT MAARTEN (GREAT BAY) - The Police Force of Sint Maarten (KPSM) wishes to provide an update regarding the ongoing investigation into the kidnapping of two men that took place on Richmond Drive in Cole Bay on Monday, November 9, 2026. During the course of the investigation,...

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...